This is the filed review document, copied at 09:19 EDT. Its dated claims remain historical. See the current update before acting on an old sign-in request or delivery status. Reply in chat with decisions or feedback.
{
"schema_version": 2,
"status": "proposal only; no Honcho writes and no source-record changes; the team-safe batch is proposed and its write is held; restricted candidates are held",
"peer": "justanother",
"workspace": "captain",
"observation_date": "2026-10-20",
"production_state": {
"memory_flags": "off; no flag changed in this work (ledger rows 54 and 73; round-3/activation-readiness.md)",
"ja_admitted_sessions": "cached settings list no JA sessions, and the JA permission path refuses reads with 'JA memory has no admitted sessions' (round-3/activation-readiness.md, JA seed row)",
"writes": "none made; any write waits for Toberton's word and one readback of the final count (ledger row 62)"
},
"checkout": {
"path": "/Users/toberton/orca/workspaces/JustAnother/astra-jr-seed-proposals",
"branch": "altriasagent/astra-jr-seed-proposals",
"base_head": "8c59dd9a353bfa8c58bfc2a339a58aa168d3fcdd",
"origin": "https://github.com/altriasagent/JustAnother.git",
"changes_at_start": "none (git status clean)"
},
"audience_labels": {
"team": "may appear in any JA group forum or reply; the only label used by the team-safe batch",
"toberton_only": "personnel, private-communication and personal-overlay material; private replies to Toberton only; default for anything from a personal debrief; broadened only by explicit permission in the source"
},
"write_policy": {
"team_batch": "proposed; every write is held for Toberton's word and one readback",
"restricted": "held; not proposed for writing until a separate implementation check proves retrieval isolation",
"mixed_audience_single_peer": "never proposed. The single justanother peer does not enforce per-conclusion audience labels, so a label in this file is proposal metadata, not protection"
},
"peer_card": [
{
"id": "P01",
"text": "Name: JustAnother (JA), an event business",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "AGENTS.md", "location": "lines 3-5"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated operating guide, read as current on 2026-10-20",
"rationale": "Opening identity line; the business is named in the root operating guide.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P02",
"text": "Legal entity: Just Another Holdings LLC (New York)",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "legal (name only)",
"source": [
{"path": "legal/formation/JA Holdings LLC NY Formation Document.pdf", "location": "page 1, Articles of Organization, item FIRST; NYS filing stamp 03/27/2026"},
{"path": "STATUS.md", "location": "line 521 (name in prose)"}
],
"source_date": "2026-03-27",
"source_date_note": "Filing stamp date on the articles",
"rationale": "The name comes from the filed articles, not the JA Holdings LLC filenames. Filing number, registered-agent address and other formation details are left out.",
"contradictions": ["C-ENTITY"],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P03",
"text": "Founder: Toberton (team.md writes Tobi O.)",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 9"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "States the owner's name and the roster's own label for him.",
"contradictions": ["C-TOBI"],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P04",
"text": "Co-Founder, Community & Vibe Curation: Tobi A., a different person from Toberton",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "lines 10 and 19-21"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The roster's own title for Tobi A., with the distinction the roster states.",
"contradictions": ["C-TOBI"],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P05",
"text": "Name note: 'Tobi' alone does not identify Toberton or Tobi A.",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [
{"path": "team.md", "location": "lines 19-21"},
{"path": ".agents/skills/ja-meetings/SKILL.md", "location": "line 79 ('The two-Tobi trap')"}
],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated; skill text as present in the checkout on 2026-10-20",
"rationale": "Meeting transcripts and the WOB-72 scope both use the bare name, so the card states the ambiguity as a fact about names.",
"contradictions": ["C-TOBI"],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P06",
"text": "Regional Lead, JA DC (team.md marks the role '(forward)'): Ben (Slack: Big Ben)",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 15"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "Carries the roster's own '(forward)' marker without deciding what it means.",
"contradictions": [],
"uncertainties": ["U-FORWARD"],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P07",
"text": "Sound + Resident DJ: Osa (Slack: Mudia)",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [
{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 12"},
{"path": "playbooks/slack.md", "location": "line 22 (the 'Mudia' label)"}
],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "Maps the Slack display name to the person.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P08",
"text": "Brand Partnerships & Guest Experience (co-lead): Deja (Slack: Wynndee)",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [
{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 13"},
{"path": "playbooks/slack.md", "location": "line 17 (the 'Deja's lane' label)"}
],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "Maps the Slack display name and the roster title.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P09",
"text": "Brand Partnerships & Guest Experience (co-lead): Chrissy",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 14"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The roster title for Chrissy. Her scope is in E06.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "P10",
"text": "Creative, Brand & Content (listed as incoming): Makala",
"destination": "peer_card",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 11 (the roster's '(incoming)' marker, kept exactly)"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "Keeps the roster's exact incoming status. Active work is recorded separately as an inference (I-MAKALA) and is not written.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
}
],
"explicit_conclusions": [
{
"id": "E01",
"text": "justanother runs one-off events, recurring classes (Pilates, spin, run club and dance), merch and social content",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [
{"path": "playbooks/slack.md", "location": "lines 14-16"},
{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 9 (merch in Toberton's lane)"}
],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated",
"rationale": "What the business does, so a request can be placed in the right lane.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E02",
"text": "Toberton's lane is strategy and go/no-go decisions, economics, finance, venue terms and contracts, creative direction and final visual output, merch, LLC and compliance",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none (roster role description, no figures)",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 9"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The roster's own description of the founder's lane.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E03",
"text": "Tobi A.'s lane is community and hospitality, audience growth and engagement, partner and host touchpoints, event calendar coordination, and live mic and DJ transitions",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 10"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The roster's description of the co-founder's lane.",
"contradictions": ["C-TOBI"],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E04",
"text": "Osa's lane is sound curation, AV and gear, DJ screening and scorecard, run-of-show sound, and resident DJ work",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 12"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The sound lane's scope.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E05",
"text": "Deja's lane is sponsor and partner touchpoints, guest experience and the door, and day-of capture coordination",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 13"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The partnerships lane's scope.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E06",
"text": "Chrissy's lane is sponsor and brand-partnership sourcing and activation, and guest experience and the door",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 14"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "The partnerships lane's scope, parallel to E05.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E07",
"text": "Ben runs the JA DC standup and has the final say on door comp exceptions and live door-price changes at events Ben attends",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 15"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "A standing role for one teammate, so a door question reaches the right person. The door standard itself is not seeded.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E08",
"text": "Makala's listed lane is creative direction with Toberton, visual identity consistency, social and content creation, non-party creative initiatives, and systems hygiene",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 11 (the lane column, under the '(incoming)' marker)"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated roster",
"rationale": "States the listed scope only. Whether that work is active now is the separate inference I-MAKALA.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
},
{
"id": "E09",
"text": "JustAnother™ is the outward name, JA the internal shorthand, and JARD the historical name of the rooftop series",
"destination": "explicit_conclusion",
"audience": "team",
"sensitivity": "none",
"source": [{"path": "AGENTS.md", "location": "lines 61-63"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated",
"rationale": "Identity and naming history. This is not a drafting rule for any agent.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "proposed_write_held"
}
],
"restricted_held": [
{
"id": "R01",
"text": "Naeem, the former partner and creative lead, departed in June 2026 and is no longer on the JA team",
"destination": "restricted_held",
"audience": "toberton_only",
"sensitivity": "personnel and legal; the closed separation record is not referenced",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "lines 23-24"}],
"source_date": "2026-06",
"source_date_note": "Month stated in team.md; day not recorded",
"rationale": "Keeps a former partner from being treated as a current contact. Held for retrieval isolation.",
"status": "held_no_write"
},
{
"id": "R02",
"text": "Patrice (Pat) is no longer on the JA team; Toberton confirmed this on 8 September 2026, and no departure date is recorded",
"destination": "restricted_held",
"audience": "toberton_only",
"sensitivity": "personnel",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "lines 26-28"}],
"source_date": "2026-09-08",
"source_date_note": "Confirmation date stated in team.md",
"rationale": "Same purpose as R01. The source records no departure date, so none is proposed.",
"status": "held_no_write"
},
{
"id": "R03",
"text": "Kevin is no longer part of the JA team; Toberton confirmed this on 27 September 2026",
"destination": "restricted_held",
"audience": "toberton_only",
"sensitivity": "personnel",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "lines 30-31"}],
"source_date": "2026-09-27",
"source_date_note": "Confirmation date stated in team.md",
"rationale": "Dated departure claim retained from the roster. Later STATUS mentions are not used as evidence of a current role.",
"contradictions": [],
"status": "held_no_write"
},
{
"id": "R04",
"text": "Chrissy's work reaches Toberton through his Messages thread with her rather than through Slack",
"destination": "restricted_held",
"audience": "toberton_only",
"sensitivity": "private communication channel",
"source": [{"path": "team.md", "location": "line 14"}],
"source_date": "2026-09-15",
"source_date_note": "Toberton confirmation date stated in team.md",
"rationale": "A routing fact, but it describes Toberton's private channel, so it stays with him.",
"status": "held_no_write"
},
{
"id": "R05",
"text": "Toberton treats finance, reconciliation, legal, governance, personnel, partner-sensitive work, early ideas and personal operations as private-by-default records",
"destination": "restricted_held",
"audience": "toberton_only",
"sensitivity": "private (his placement preference; personal overlay)",
"source": [{"path": "/Users/toberton/projects/agent-setup/local/justanother/AGENTS.local.md", "location": "lines 27-29 (Toberton's uncommitted overlay)"}],
"source_date": null,
"source_date_note": "Undated overlay",
"rationale": "A preference that describes his own boundaries. Its source is personal, so the default stays with him.",
"status": "held_no_write"
}
],
"inferences_not_proposed": [
{
"id": "I-MAKALA",
"text": "Makala probably holds active social and creative work now",
"kind": "inference from operating records, not a roster fact",
"basis": [
{"path": "playbooks/slack.md", "location": "line 15 names #socialmedia as Makala's lane"},
{"path": "STATUS.md", "location": "lines 107-110, an October 8 kit packaged for Makala's work"}
],
"why_not_written": "team.md says incoming; the roster stays exact in P10 and E08. The inference could be true while the role is still listed as incoming, so it is not written as a fact.",
"status": "not_proposed"
},
{
"id": "I-WOB72-TOBI",
"text": "The 'teammate Tobi' in the WOB-72 scope is Tobi A.",
"kind": "inference from recorded roles and an observed local alias",
"basis": [
{"path": "Linear WOB-72, accepted-scope table", "location": "names Toberton and Ben as the core, and 'teammate Tobi' as a third person; the same issue says to keep Ben, teammate Tobi and owner Toberton distinct"},
{"path": "team.md", "location": "lines 9-10 list Toberton as Founder and Tobi A. as the co-founder, the only other Tobi on the roster"},
{"path": "meetings/team/huddle-0811-minutes.md", "location": "line 5, 'Tobz' in the present list (a local record; no live Slack lookup was made)"},
{"path": ".agents/skills/ja-meetings/SKILL.md", "location": "line 79 says Tobi A. appears as 'Tobes' or 'Tobz'"}
],
"implementation_check": "Before any permission path matches 'teammate Tobi', resolve it to Tobi A.'s immutable Slack user ID, not a display name or the 'Tobi' string. This is an implementation check, not a new permission choice.",
"status": "not_proposed"
}
],
"exclusions": [
{"id": "X01", "topic": "Dated event status and plans (for example the November brunch, Mat & Mingle, Afrofusion, Kyma Lagos, JAM!, V)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Time-bound and task-like; a stored line would read as current after it stopped being true.", "home": "events/<event>/ records and each event's Slack List", "sources": ["STATUS.md", "events/README.md"]},
{"id": "X02", "topic": "Venue names, shortlists, outreach, contacts and terms", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Another worker owns venue extraction, and venue facts are not team memory.", "home": "venue-sourcing/ and event venue records", "sources": ["venue-sourcing/README.md"]},
{"id": "X03", "topic": "Finance: revenue, costs, payouts, budgets, deposits, ticket counts, yields, bank details, account data", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Not needed for useful memory; WOB-72 limits who may see it. Event finance analysis rules are procedure, not owner facts.", "home": "finance records and event reconciliations", "sources": ["events/AGENTS.md", "Linear WOB-72 accepted-scope table"]},
{"id": "X04", "topic": "Who may see or change what (any access or permission statement)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "The seed is not an authorization source. Permissions live in WOB-72 and the implementation record.", "home": "Linear WOB-72 and WOB-57", "sources": ["Linear WOB-72"]},
{"id": "X05", "topic": "Credentials, phone numbers, street and registered-agent addresses", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Named exclusion in the memory guidance; none is needed for memory.", "home": "Keychain and the contacts tool", "sources": ["memory-seed-guidance-2026-10-03.md, 'What not to seed'"]},
{"id": "X06", "topic": "All email addresses, including Ben's verified JA address and Toberton's account addresses, whatever the domain", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Email addresses are not memory. The .biz and .nyc addresses can coexist, so no domain question is raised for this seed.", "home": "the mail system and contacts", "sources": ["team.md line 17", "playbooks/gmail.md lines 3-4"]},
{"id": "X07", "topic": "Agent operating permissions and authority gates: banking write authority, Instagram/Square/Partiful write authority, the go/no-go gate list, and any hook, setting or credentialed-automation permission", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "These are runtime permission rules for agents, not stable facts about the business. They stay in AGENTS.md and the access records.", "home": "AGENTS.md (lines 23-27), Toberton's overlay (lines 17-18), access records", "sources": ["AGENTS.md lines 23-27"]},
{"id": "X08", "topic": "Tool, repo-path, bot or app identity, and Slack channel-ID inventories", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Infrastructure inventories go stale and are not team facts.", "home": "playbooks/tooling.md and agent-setup records", "sources": ["playbooks/tooling.md"]},
{"id": "X09", "topic": "Slack channel routing, room kit, readback format, Slack List placement, event-folder structure and the playbook index", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Rule-like workflow inventory. These are read at the point of use from the owning playbook or README, not stored as memory.", "home": "playbooks/slack.md, events/README.md, playbooks/README.md", "sources": ["playbooks/slack.md", "events/README.md", "playbooks/README.md"]},
{"id": "X10", "topic": "Agent rules (hold outward sends for a yes, one checklist at session end, read AGENTS.md first, commit rules)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "The memory guidance keeps rules out of conclusions, because a conclusion is read as a fact about the person or business.", "home": "AGENTS.md, the overlay and the skills", "sources": ["memory-seed-guidance-2026-10-03.md, 'What not to seed'"]},
{"id": "X11", "topic": "Raw instruction text and quoted messages", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "A quote is not a fact; the seed carries paraphrased facts with their sources.", "home": "source files", "sources": ["memory-seed-guidance-2026-10-03.md"]},
{"id": "X12", "topic": "Meeting content: minutes, debriefs, transcripts and what anyone said in them", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Discussion is not a stable fact, and transcripts carry mis-hearings. The collector seams S4-S6 govern any later promotion.", "home": "meetings/ records", "sources": ["meetings/team/ja-one-debrief-0810.md", "meetings/partnerships/lavender-room/2026-10-11-intro-call-transcript-raw.md", "ledger row 57"]},
{"id": "X13", "topic": "Personal-only records and Himmerton-linked material", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "WOB-72 says these remain private. This proposal does not characterize them.", "home": "Toberton's private records", "sources": ["Linear WOB-72 accepted-scope table"]},
{"id": "X14", "topic": "Personnel and legal detail beyond the roster statements in R01-R03 (the separation record, departure circumstances)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Only the dated roster claims are kept, and they are held. The closed legal record is not referenced.", "home": "legal/agreement-separation/ (closed record)", "sources": ["team.md lines 23-31"]},
{"id": "X15", "topic": "Memory-architecture decisions (the justanother peer, JA-facing reads, the JA permission flags)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "A description of the system, not of JA.", "home": "docs/decisions/ledger-2026-10-19.md rows 61-64", "sources": ["docs/decisions/ledger-2026-10-19.md"]},
{"id": "X16", "topic": "Claude auto-memory entries", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Agent-side memory, not a JA source record. Not opened in this pass.", "home": "Claude project memory", "sources": ["MEMORY.md index (listed, not opened)"]},
{"id": "X17", "topic": "Personal peer examples from the Oct 3 memory guidance (dog-walking, INSTRUCTION-prefixed card examples)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "They describe Toberton's own peer and carry over to JA by no fact.", "home": "Toberton's personal peer", "sources": ["memory-seed-guidance-2026-10-03.md, 'Writing shape'"]},
{"id": "X18", "topic": "Event-specific payment, approval and exclusion decisions, and the rule that they stay scoped to one event", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "A procedural rule for event analysis, not a standing fact.", "home": "events/AGENTS.md and each event record", "sources": ["events/AGENTS.md, 'Event finances'"]},
{"id": "X19", "topic": "Brand phrasing from a call transcript (the 'curated third space' line)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Spoken on a call, not an approved brand line.", "home": "brand/ and Toberton's decision", "sources": ["meetings/partnerships/lavender-room/2026-10-11-intro-call-transcript-raw.md"]},
{"id": "X20", "topic": "Event-scoped external partners and their staff", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "A partner can lead an event without being on the roster, so no roster or role entry is implied. The event-specific role is omitted.", "home": "events/brunchin/ and meetings/partnerships/", "sources": ["team.md"]},
{"id": "X21", "topic": "Dated status lines (channel counts, weekly operating updates, mail updates)", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Time-bound and superseded quickly.", "home": "STATUS.md and Slack Lists", "sources": ["STATUS.md line 3"]},
{"id": "X22", "topic": "JR's overhaul, JR spec files and JR access implementation", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Owned by Astra in this checkout; not seed material.", "home": "Astra's JR spec files and WOB-57", "sources": ["round-3/activation-readiness.md"]},
{"id": "X23", "topic": "A third 'Tobi' named as an external partner in a proposal reference file", "disposition": "excluded", "reason": "Not on the roster, and the file is a reference example rather than a record of a current relationship.", "home": "the reference file itself", "sources": [".agents/skills/ja-pdf/references/esc-proposal-reference.py line 839"]}
],
"noncontradictions": [
{"id": "NC-DOMAIN", "claim_a": "Ben's JA address is ben@justanother.biz, verified on 12 October 2026 (team.md line 17)", "claim_b": "Toberton's Google Workspace primary admin moved to a justanother.nyc account on 15 August 2026 (finance filing note, line 818; playbooks/gmail.md lines 3-4)", "treatment": "Both can hold at once; a Workspace can contain both domains. No address is written (X06), so no question is raised."},
{"id": "NC-MAKALA", "claim_a": "Makala is listed as incoming (team.md line 11)", "claim_b": "Makala's lane is named as live in playbooks/slack.md line 15, and October work is recorded in STATUS (lines 107-110)", "treatment": "A person can be listed as incoming and hold responsibilities. The roster status stays exact (P10); the active-work reading is the separate inference I-MAKALA."},
{"id": "NC-KEVIN", "claim_a": "Kevin is no longer part of the JA team, confirmed 27 September 2026 (team.md lines 30-31)", "claim_b": "Later STATUS mentions of a person named Kevin", "treatment": "The dated roster claim stands as R03. Those mentions are not used as evidence of a current role, and their identity is not analyzed."},
{"id": "NC-BRITT", "claim_a": "Britt leads an event partnership with JA (STATUS and the kickoff record)", "claim_b": "Britt is not on team.md", "treatment": "An event partner does not need roster membership, so the event-specific role is omitted (X20)."}
],
"contradictions": [
{
"id": "C-ENTITY",
"claim_a": "The articles of organization name the company JUST ANOTHER HOLDINGS LLC (legal/formation PDF, page 1, item FIRST)",
"claim_b": "Filenames and a calendar title shorten the name to JA Holdings LLC or Tobi JA LLC (.gitignore line 51; STATUS.md line 496)",
"disposition": "resolved: the filed name is used; the shorter forms are shorthand, not a second entity",
"resolver": "the filed articles"
},
{
"id": "C-TOBI",
"claim_a": "'Tobi' names Toberton (Tobi O.) and Tobi A. is a separate co-founder (team.md lines 9-10, 19-21)",
"claim_b": "The bare name appears in a call transcript label for Toberton (lavender-room transcript line 4), in a huddle roster as 'Tobz' (huddle-0811 line 5), and in the WOB-72 scope as 'teammate Tobi'",
"disposition": "handled, not resolved by the source: P05 states the naming fact; I-WOB72-TOBI is an inference with an implementation check",
"resolver": "the implementation check in I-WOB72-TOBI"
}
],
"dependencies": [
{"id": "D-WRITE", "text": "All writes wait for Toberton's word and one readback of the final count (ledger row 62). Nothing in this file is a write instruction."},
{"id": "D-ISOLATION", "text": "Restricted candidates can be written only after a separate implementation check proves retrieval isolation, such as a separate peer or an enforced reader filter. The audience labels alone do not do this, and the team batch carries only team-audience items."},
{"id": "D-LEDGER-58", "text": "A later deletion from Honcho needs an export first (ledger row 58). Whether that rule covers the justanother peer is an implementation check."},
{"id": "D-LEDGER-60", "text": "A later correction write needs its scope confirmed for the justanother peer, because ledger row 60 covers memories about Toberton. This is an implementation dependency, not a current question."}
],
"uncertainties": [
{"id": "U-FORWARD", "text": "What the '(forward)' marker on Ben's role means is not stated in team.md. P06 carries it unchanged."},
{"id": "U-DATE-ROSTER", "text": "team.md is undated. The dated facts inside it are the only time anchors; the rest carry source_date null."},
{"id": "U-AUDIENCE-ENFORCE", "text": "Retrieval isolation has not been tested. No service was called, and ledger row 69 says logical separation is not proof of enforcement."},
{"id": "U-SLACK-ID", "text": "The Tobi A. mapping has no immutable Slack ID. The observed 'Tobz' alias comes from a local record, and no live Slack lookup was made."},
{"id": "U-PDF-PAGES", "text": "The formation PDF was read on page 1 only. The entity name is taken from page 1."}
],
"collector_seams": [
{"id": "S1", "seam": "team.md roster rows", "emits": "one candidate per roster row, with the row, its line and its commit date as provenance", "on_update": "a new candidate with the new commit date; the old one is superseded, not deleted", "on_deletion": "marked retired_by_source; no Honcho delete is proposed (D-LEDGER-58)", "on_correction": "a candidate citing both versions until the replacement is approved", "audience": "team, because the roster is a team document"},
{"id": "S2", "seam": "playbooks/*.md and event READMEs", "emits": "identity and lane facts that the documents state; routing rules are excluded (X09)", "on_update": "as S1", "on_deletion": "as S1", "on_correction": "as S1", "audience": "team only where the document is team-facing; otherwise toberton_only"},
{"id": "S3", "seam": "AGENTS.md (shared) and the overlay", "emits": "identity and naming facts only; permission and operating rules are excluded (X07, X10)", "on_update": "as S1", "on_deletion": "as S1", "on_correction": "as S1", "audience": "AGENTS.md identity facts team; overlay facts toberton_only"},
{"id": "S4", "seam": "meeting minutes ('What was decided') and call summaries", "emits": "a decision, keyed to the meeting date from the filename; the 'Present' line is context only", "speaker_rule": "A Present list says who attended, not who said a line, so this seam never attributes a statement to a named person", "audience": "toberton_only unless the source states the decision is team-level"},
{"id": "S5", "seam": "transcripts (cleaned, speaker-labelled, and raw machine versions)", "emits": "evidence only; no candidate about a speaker's view", "speaker_rule": "The raw version has no labels, and the cleaned labels are machine guesses. Ledger row 57 bars recording any capture turn as either peer's words.", "audience": "not seeded"},
{"id": "S6", "seam": "personal debriefs (for example meetings/team/ja-one-debrief-0810.md, made from Toberton's voice memo)", "emits": "candidates only after two fields are set: account_of (Toberton) and mentioned (the people named)", "speaker_rule": "Everything in a debrief is Toberton's account of what others did or said. A candidate never carries a speaker field unless a transcript or a direct quote supports it.", "audience": "toberton_only by default; broadened only by explicit permission in the source"},
{"id": "S7", "seam": "STATUS.md dated entries", "emits": "decisions only; status lines are dropped by a date-window rule (X21)", "on_update": "as S1", "on_deletion": "as S1", "on_correction": "as S1", "audience": "toberton_only unless the entry states a team-level decision"},
{"id": "S8", "seam": "Slack Lists and Linear issues (live services)", "emits": "nothing stored; read at proposal time only to check a candidate", "rule": "A cache is evidence, not truth (AGENTS.md line 16), and live tasks stay with their owners", "audience": "not seeded"}
],
"sources_read": [
"/Users/toberton/orca/workspaces/agent-setup/astra-overnight-20261020/docs/plan-2/overnight-handoff-2026-10-20/briefs/ja-seed-proposal.md (re-read)",
"/Users/toberton/projects/agent-setup/instructions/writing-guide.md (re-read)",
"AGENTS.md (JA root)", "events/AGENTS.md", "events/README.md", "playbooks/README.md", "playbooks/slack.md", "playbooks/gmail.md (lines 1-5)",
"team.md", "STATUS.md (front matter, Makala, Kevin, Britt, LLC and domain lines, operating references)",
"Toberton's overlay AGENTS.local.md (read at its agent-setup target)",
"meetings/ tree and the headers of six meeting files; meetings/team/huddle-0811-minutes.md line 5",
".agents/skills/ja-meetings/SKILL.md (section 4 and headings)",
"legal/formation/JA Holdings LLC NY Formation Document.pdf (page 1 image)",
"agent-setup docs/plan-2/interview-2026-10-18/approved-delivery.md; round-3/approval-notes.md; round-3/activation-readiness.md",
"agent-setup docs/decisions/ledger-2026-10-19.md (rows 54, 57, 58, 60, 62, 63, 64, 69, 73)",
"agent-setup docs/plan-2/workstream-a-plan-2026-10-18.md (I01, W03, M03 rows)",
"WobOS-implementation-20261016 memory-seed-guidance-2026-10-03.md",
"agent-setup build-delivery references/worker-handoff.md",
"Linear WOB-72 (read-only get_issue, status Done)"
]
}